Sexual violence and hate speech
Indicators of conflict-related sexual violence
Although CIR has not seen or verified any footage depicting conflict-related sexual violence (CRSV), analysis of other footage from El Fasher shows potential proxy indicators of CRSV.
As identified in Bellingcat’s guidance on recognising Sexual and Gender-Based Violence in open-source research, separation of men and women in conflict settings can serve as an early warning sign of CRSV. When armed actors or authorities deliberately separate women and men—such as in detention sites or areas under their control—it can indicate that women and girls are being isolated for sexual abuse or assault. In footage reviewed by CIR, including scenes of detentions, only men are visible, with no women (or children) present. This absence may suggest deliberate separation, raising concern that sexual violence could be occurring or is being prepared for. While separation alone does not prove CRSV, it is a recognised risk indicator.
In addition, in verified footage showing RSF commander Abu Lulu, he can be heard saying: “There’s one [woman] they call Umm Falaga, I’m [looking for her].” ‘Umm Falaga’ translates as “the woman with a gap between her teeth”. Such statements and the singling out of women are also indicators of potential CRSV.
Combined with pattern analysis of reports from other areas under RSF control and the likelihood that a large part of the population remains in the city, this raises grave concern for women trapped in El Fasher.
Hate speech and incitement to violence
CIR observed instances of humiliating treatment by the RSF towards detained individuals in multiple videos, as well as incitement to violence and hate speech by RSF supporters online. While it is difficult to verify perpetrator intent, analysis of common narratives by RSF fighters and their supporters sheds light on possible motives.
Some of these instances illustrate the unfounded accusations that all men captured by the RSF are accused of collaborating with or being supportive of the SAF, a common allegation used to justify their detention and execution by RSF. In one video posted to Facebook on 27 October, a RSF fighter coerces detainees at gunpoint to state “we’re all militants” before executing them. [3]
In other videos, men are made to praise the RSF. On 29 October, a pro-SAF Telegram channel posted a video showing fighters coercing three detained individuals in civilian clothing to praise the RSF, make animal sounds, and recite, “Abu Lulu is my master” and “[Unit] 145 rise” before shooting them. It is important to also note here that humiliation of detainees can also be an early warning indicator of CRSV, as per Bellingcat’s guidance on red flags.
CIR also observed the use of ethnic slurs directed at individuals in civilian clothing fleeing from El Fasher. On 27 October, a pro-SAF Telegram channel posted a video showing individuals being shot at from the back by RSF fighters in a moving vehicle. The man filming can be heard shouting:
“[Shoot] them (x4), [shoot] them man, [shoot] them. (unintelligible) f*ck their mothers those people. […] Just [shoot] them, beat them, Nuba sons of b*tches”
While the term ‘Nuba’ refers to ethnic groups from the Nuba Mountains, CIR observed it being widely used by RSF fighters as a derogatory term for non-Arabs in Darfur.